Tier 4 Systematic

WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY

📍 3020 STATE AVE., BILLINGS, MT 59101🏭 Industry Sector 00📅 1996-11-26
$35,825.50
Total Penalties
103
Citations
47/100
Risk Score
361
Analysis Words
Enforcement Analysis

According to U.S. Department of Labor enforcement records, WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY — a industry sector 00 facility located at 3020 STATE AVE., BILLINGS, MT 59101 — was the subject of a formal OSHA inspection that resulted in 103 citation(s) and cumulative proposed penalties of $35,825.50. The inspection case was opened on 1996-11-26.

The volume of citations issued during this inspection suggests systematic compliance deficiencies rather than isolated incidents. Facilities with 10 or more citations typically face comprehensive abatement requirements and may be subject to follow-up inspections.

State Context: Within MT, this facility's penalty places it at the 99th percentile among 9,480 inspected facilities. The statewide average penalty is $2,110.71.

Citation Analysis: The inspection produced 103 citations spanning 10 distinct OSHA regulatory standards. The citation breakdown includes: 10 other-than-serious — The violation has a direct relationship to job safety and health but is unlikely to cause death or serious physical harm. 4 serious — A workplace hazard that could cause death or serious physical harm exists, and the employer knew or should have known about the condition. 1 repeat — A substantially similar violation was found during a previous inspection and the original citation has become a final order.

Enforcement Timeline: Citations were issued beginning September 21, 1992 with the latest abatement deadline set for November 15, 1997. Of the 103 total citations, 15 (15%) have been marked as abated in DOL records, which may indicate ongoing compliance gaps requiring further regulatory attention.

Penalty Assessment: The cumulative penalty of $35,825.50 reflects OSHA's gravity-based penalty calculation methodology, which considers the severity of potential injury, the probability of occurrence, the employer's size, good faith, and violation history. The per-citation average of $347.82 falls within the standard penalty range.

The enforcement record for Western Sugar Company’s Billings facility reveals a pervasive breakdown in safety management systems, characterized

Citation Matrix — 103 Citations
29 CFR 1910.23(c)(01)
Guarding Floor & Wall Openings
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: February 13, 1997Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.212(a)(01)
Machine Guarding — General Requirements
Serious
Penalty: $1,000.00Gravity: 02Issued: September 21, 1992Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.219(d)(01)
Mechanical Power Transmission
Serious
Penalty: $1,000.00Gravity: 01Issued: September 21, 1992Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.179(j)(02)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: September 21, 1992Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.215(b)(09)
Abrasive Wheel Machinery
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: September 21, 1992Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.242(b)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: September 21, 1992Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.176(f)
Serious
Penalty: $5,000.00Gravity: 10Issued: April 1, 1993Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.1200(f)(05)
Hazard Communication Standard (Chemical Safety)
Repeat
Penalty: $500.00Gravity: 01Issued: April 1, 1993Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.212(a)(01)
Machine Guarding — General Requirements
Serious
Penalty: $750.00Gravity: 03Issued: December 31, 1996Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.1200(h)(03)
Hazard Communication Standard (Chemical Safety)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: December 31, 1996Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.1200(h)(03)
Hazard Communication Standard (Chemical Safety)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: December 31, 1996Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.134(b)(01)
Fall Protection — General Requirements
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: April 14, 1997Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.134(e)(05)
Fall Protection — General Requirements
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: April 14, 1997Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.1000(a)(02)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: April 14, 1997Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.1000(e)
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $0.00Gravity: 01Issued: April 14, 1997Abated: ✓ Yes
This report is compiled from publicly available U.S. Department of Labor enforcement data under the Freedom of Information Act. SVEP Navigator is an independent research and analysis platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to OSHA, the Department of Labor, or any federal agency. Information is provided for research, educational, and compliance planning purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Penalty amounts shown are proposed penalties and may have been modified through contest proceedings or settlement.
More MT Enforcement Records
ASARCO, INC.
EAST HELENA, MT
$836.9K
213 cit.
MONTANA REFINING CO.
GREAT FALLS, MT
$520.1K
105 cit.
PASTA MONTANA, LLC
GREAT FALLS, MT
$279.2K
6 cit.
NELCON, INC.
LAUREL, MT
$184.2K
28 cit.
MONTANA POWER COMPANY
COLSTRIP, MT
$176.4K
24 cit.
Other Inspected Facilities in BILLINGS, MT
DOLLAR TREE STORES, INC., #2828
$152.1K
4 cit.
MEADOW GOLD DAIRIES, INC. DBA DEAN FOODS
$79.8K
20 cit.
POLAR CORPORATION
$55.0K
14 cit.
NORTHWESTERN ENERGY, INC.
$55.0K
2 cit.
ROSEBUD OPERATING SERVICES, INC.
$52.1K
52 cit.
Related Guides & Tools
OSHA Fines & Penalties Guide →
How OSHA calculates penalties and maximum fine amounts.
After an OSHA Inspection →
Citations, appeals, and penalty negotiation steps.
Top 10 OSHA Violations →
The most frequently cited standards nationwide.
Penalty Calculator →
Estimate fines by violation type, industry, and size.

Explore more: OSHA enforcement in BILLINGS · Montana data · Search the database · Incident Rate Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions
What OSHA violations was WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY cited for?

WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY received 103 citation(s) covering 10 distinct OSHA standards. Total proposed penalties were $35,825.50. The inspection opened on 1996-11-26.

How much was WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY fined by OSHA?

OSHA proposed penalties of $35,825.50 against WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY in BILLINGS, MT. Average per citation: $347.82.

Is WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY a safe workplace?

Based on enforcement records, WESTERN SUGAR COMPANY has a risk score of 47 out of 100. The volume of citations issued during this inspection suggests systematic compliance deficiencies rather than isolated incidents. Facilities with 10 or more citations typically face comprehensive abatement requirements and may be subject to follow-up inspections.

How does this penalty compare to the industry average?

The average penalty for Industry Sector 00 facilities is $1,195.75. This facility penalty of $35,825.50 is above the industry average.