Tier 5 Standard

BUDGET TOWING

📍 1145 HOMER AVE, ST PAUL, MN 55116🏭 Motor Vehicle Towing (NAICS 488410)📅 2005-06-06
$26,250.00
Total Penalties
4
Citations
7/100
Risk Score
406
Analysis Words
Enforcement Analysis

According to U.S. Department of Labor enforcement records, BUDGET TOWING — a motor vehicle towing facility located at 1145 HOMER AVE, ST PAUL, MN 55116 — was the subject of a formal OSHA inspection that resulted in 4 citation(s) and cumulative proposed penalties of $26,250.00. The inspection case was opened on 2005-06-06.

DOL records document workplace safety violations warranting formal citation under the OSH Act. While classified at the standard enforcement level, all OSHA citations require corrective action and may indicate areas where workplace safety programs should be strengthened.

BLS Injury Data: According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (2022), this industry sector has an occupational injury rate of 4.6 per 100 full-time workers — 70% above the national average of 2.7. The sector fatality rate is 14.0 per 100,000 workers.

Industry Benchmark: The total penalty of $26,250.00 is more than 6.2× the national average of $4,244.13 for facilities in the Transportation sector (NAICS 488410). This sector encompasses 17,047 inspected facilities nationwide with aggregate penalties totaling $72.3M.

State Context: Within MN, this facility's penalty places it at the 99th percentile among 58,337 inspected facilities. The statewide average penalty is $1,403.06.

Citation Analysis: The inspection produced 4 citations spanning 3 distinct OSHA regulatory standards. The citation breakdown includes: 3 serious — A workplace hazard that could cause death or serious physical harm exists, and the employer knew or should have known about the condition. 1 other-than-serious — The violation has a direct relationship to job safety and health but is unlikely to cause death or serious physical harm.

Enforcement Timeline: Citations were issued beginning October 26, 2005 with the latest abatement deadline set for November 23, 2005. Of the 4 total citations, 3 (75%) have been marked as abated in DOL records, suggesting partial progress toward required corrective actions.

Penalty Assessment: The cumulative penalty of $26,250.00 reflects OSHA's gravity-based penalty calculation methodology, which considers the severity of potential injury, the probability of occurrence, the employer's size, good faith, and violation history. The per-citation average of $6,562.50 falls within the standard penalty range.

The enforcement profile for Budget Towing reveals a catastrophic failure in managing atmospheric hazards, overshadowed by a

Industry Benchmark (MN)

This facility's $26,250 penalty is higher than 91% of all penalized companies in the NAICS 488410 industry in MN. The state average penalty for this industry is $5,768.

$5,768
State Avg
$26,250
This Facility
Citation Matrix — 4 Citations
29 CFR 1910.147(c)(04)
Control of Hazardous Energy (Lockout/Tagout)
Serious
Penalty: $525.00Gravity: nanIssued: October 26, 2005Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 1910.147(c)(07)
Control of Hazardous Energy (Lockout/Tagout)
Serious
Penalty: $525.00Gravity: nanIssued: October 26, 2005Abated: ✓ Yes
29 CFR 5205.670
Serious
Penalty: $25,000.00Gravity: nanIssued: October 26, 2005Abated: Pending
29 CFR 1904.29(a)
Recordkeeping — Injury & Illness Log
Other-than-Serious
Penalty: $200.00Gravity: nanIssued: October 26, 2005Abated: ✓ Yes
This report is compiled from publicly available U.S. Department of Labor enforcement data under the Freedom of Information Act. SVEP Navigator is an independent research and analysis platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to OSHA, the Department of Labor, or any federal agency. Information is provided for research, educational, and compliance planning purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Penalty amounts shown are proposed penalties and may have been modified through contest proceedings or settlement.
Local Competitor Benchmark

Comparing penalized facilities in ST PAUL, MN (Broader Sector)

BUDGET TOWING (This Facility)
$26.3K
4 cit.
GAVILON GRAIN LLC DBA PEAVEY COMPANY
$3.2K
3 cit.
SBS TRANSPORATION INC
$2.5K
1 cit.
US AIRWAYS
$2.1K
2 cit.
More MN Enforcement Records
107600 - YOUR LAKE AQUATIC PLANT MANAGEMENT LLC
SAINT PAUL, MN
$730.4K
5 cit.
107323 - WAYNE TRANSPORTS INC
VIRGINIA, MN
$621.6K
12 cit.
102615 - HYLIFE FOODS WINDOM LLC
WINDOM, MN
$242.0K
5 cit.
97526 - MEADOWLAND FARMERS COOP
LAMBERTON, MN
$232.0K
6 cit.
109588 - LANG COMPANIES INC DBA LANG FEEDS INC
EDEN VALLEY, MN
$230.7K
14 cit.
Other Inspected Facilities in ST PAUL, MN
RHSC, INC.
$85.0K
3 cit.
INDEPENDENT PAPER CO
$72.2K
4 cit.
RACHEL CONTRACTING INC
$51.7K
3 cit.
MINNESOTA BREWING COMPANY
$50.6K
39 cit.
VILLAUME INDUSTRIES INC
$46.9K
74 cit.
Related Guides & Tools
OSHA Fines & Penalties Guide →
How OSHA calculates penalties and maximum fine amounts.
After an OSHA Inspection →
Citations, appeals, and penalty negotiation steps.
Top 10 OSHA Violations →
The most frequently cited standards nationwide.
Penalty Calculator →
Estimate fines by violation type, industry, and size.

Explore more: OSHA enforcement in ST PAUL · Minnesota data · Search the database · Incident Rate Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions
What OSHA violations was BUDGET TOWING cited for?

BUDGET TOWING received 4 citation(s) covering 3 distinct OSHA standards. Total proposed penalties were $26,250.00. The inspection opened on 2005-06-06.

How much was BUDGET TOWING fined by OSHA?

OSHA proposed penalties of $26,250.00 against BUDGET TOWING in ST PAUL, MN. Average per citation: $6,562.50.

Is BUDGET TOWING a safe workplace?

Based on enforcement records, BUDGET TOWING has a risk score of 7 out of 100. DOL records document workplace safety violations warranting formal citation under the OSH Act. While classified at the standard enforcement level, all OSHA citations require corrective action and may indicate areas where workplace safety programs should be strengthened.

How does this penalty compare to the industry average?

The average penalty for Motor Vehicle Towing facilities is $4,244.13. This facility penalty of $26,250.00 is above the industry average.